06-29-2008, 10:25 AM
The atlatl as a missle weapon was superceded by the bow, although in the early stages of bows it was still in use as a hunting weapon for large game. Once you slot the spear, it's single handed like the sling.
The basic thing about a missle weapon is to deliver killing power. This is done both by impact (shock) and by cutting edge. Now, an atlatl gives a light spear with a stone spearhead a good length of throw, the one I have made has an effective range of about 40 to 50 meters. Of course, I can throw it much further, but it then lacks the knockdown power and penetration needed for say hunting. An arrow can be fitted with a head with a similar cutting surface, but being smaller, is easier to make and carry, and when shot by a reasonably trained archer, is much more accurate then the atlatl. Compare it to the accuracy of a sling, is about even. Even a novice with a bow will be more accurate! Being accurate with an atlatl takes a LOT of training. So, being practical, its archers over spearthrowers anyday.
For those interested in survival and bushcraft, it is however a very nice weapon, as it is much easier to make than a bow (half an hour ex. spears) and hunger should improve the aim :lol:
By the way, Paul, time to make a signature with your name in it, even if that is the same as you avitar name
The basic thing about a missle weapon is to deliver killing power. This is done both by impact (shock) and by cutting edge. Now, an atlatl gives a light spear with a stone spearhead a good length of throw, the one I have made has an effective range of about 40 to 50 meters. Of course, I can throw it much further, but it then lacks the knockdown power and penetration needed for say hunting. An arrow can be fitted with a head with a similar cutting surface, but being smaller, is easier to make and carry, and when shot by a reasonably trained archer, is much more accurate then the atlatl. Compare it to the accuracy of a sling, is about even. Even a novice with a bow will be more accurate! Being accurate with an atlatl takes a LOT of training. So, being practical, its archers over spearthrowers anyday.
For those interested in survival and bushcraft, it is however a very nice weapon, as it is much easier to make than a bow (half an hour ex. spears) and hunger should improve the aim :lol:
By the way, Paul, time to make a signature with your name in it, even if that is the same as you avitar name
