"How disappointing!" oh I don't know.... it's great to have necks on blocks even if only by omission... and adherence to 60 year old dogma... high risk for Prof Hingley.... I do enjoy a bit of academic jeopardy....
I also enjoy Hingley's characterisation that there have been hundreds/thousands of frenzied searches over centuries.... makes it very high credibility for whoever eventually gets it.... at very low credibility risk
I've ordered the book so we'll see if there is anything more of note.
I struggle to see how Mancetter "broadly matches" his translation "a narrow valley" but I think I align with most in here in that view.
I also enjoy Hingley's characterisation that there have been hundreds/thousands of frenzied searches over centuries.... makes it very high credibility for whoever eventually gets it.... at very low credibility risk
I've ordered the book so we'll see if there is anything more of note.
I struggle to see how Mancetter "broadly matches" his translation "a narrow valley" but I think I align with most in here in that view.
