11-08-2018, 07:46 PM
Thanks Sean - I've known of the 'traditional' kilt (ie the long wrap of tartan cloth), but wasn't aware of the particular introduction of the 'short' for that reason (apart from the fact that it was indeed worn) and its subsequent proliferation.
However, that does lead to the 'fashion' diagnosis, although the term "sympathetic magic" (which I'd not come across before - my latest hate is "optics" indeed!) is very similar.
Overall, I think the comment I'd really pass for Michael's consideration is that I think the section detracts from the rest of the paper - but that's just me perhaps.
As an aside, you might wish to review your signature ;-) - I have had to change username, update avatar - what did happen? I've never really known a forum that allows a change of username - it's certainly less secure}
However, that does lead to the 'fashion' diagnosis, although the term "sympathetic magic" (which I'd not come across before - my latest hate is "optics" indeed!) is very similar.
Overall, I think the comment I'd really pass for Michael's consideration is that I think the section detracts from the rest of the paper - but that's just me perhaps.
As an aside, you might wish to review your signature ;-) - I have had to change username, update avatar - what did happen? I've never really known a forum that allows a change of username - it's certainly less secure}
