dyeing linen

[MARCvSVIBIvSMAvRINvS]

Did you on purpose write a pathetic pseudo-moral sentence without an argument? That is at least as impolite as you say I would be be. IMO you have lost with your post, # "scholars", #last quoted sentence #other posts of yours in large numbers, any authority to judge about politeness of others. Do you want me to quote from this very forum?
This is double-moral and self-righteous behaviour, which makes your complaint outright ridiculous, at least in my eyes. Just for your records: I will definitely not venture with you any further into this, my time is too precious for me to do so, and I have a hell of a headache. So, you may have the last word on this.

Funny, where i do not speak about any one in detail, let alone naming them, you feel spoken to. where you give proper discourse in the first part of your post, you start complaining in the last sentences as if i attacked you personally. That says more about you than it does about me.

Academic scholars in general are happy with peer reviews, and indeed constructive criticism. The so called "scholars" i am talking about do not even publish articles in accepted and respected scientific magazines like Jrms and other well known historical magazines full of peer reviews, no, they publish in common magazines which have not yet been established within the scientific world and boldly state it on their personal internet pages as if it means they are well known scholars who should be believed at any time.They cannot handle any form of criticism when given.

When some of them seem to get their own self esteem out of this, and react to criticism in a way which tries to shut out every form of discussion i find that very childish to say the least.

Peer review, as well as constructive criticism brings science forward. open and two way discourse does so too. There is a line however one should not cross, and that line is a thin one, i agree with that. That is why I am happy not being a scholar, nor even do i try to come across as one, even though i am getting academic training at present.

Back on topic i would say.

M.VIB.M.