Rome\'s most able general?

[Marcus Julius]

Very interesting discussion. At least as good as the one a while back about the greatest Emperor. Indeed way too many to choose from.

Can I be allowed to throw a monkey wrench into the argument. Would anyone consider Spartacus to be either Roman or a General? One of Julius Caesar's greatnesses was his charisma, his ability to get both the common people and the men who died for him to at least respect him, if not absolutely love him. Spartacus was able to raise tens of thousands of troops from slaves, and get them capable enough to defeat how many legions?

Again, the issues of situation and timing are at hand, as he was obviously underestimated time and again. However, no one can discredit his ability to incite, inspire, and draw a following.