08-21-2007, 07:29 AM
Hi Saul and all,
interesting discussion, thanks for all your contributions. For me questions like this are a personal decision, depending on how close to original ways I can get and whether I can finance it. I do try to use materials as close to the original materials as possible, but I try to reproduce the end-product, not to reproduce ancient production itself and that is where I (roughly) draw the line. Thus I drill holes with a power drill or use saw and file to make a single, say, medical instrument from brass rather than casting it, etc. etc.
What actually is more important to me personally when talking about these things in detail with interested visitors/fellow reenactors is to openly admit to the compromises made and explain the reasoning behind instead of stubbornly maintaining to be a know-it-all who never does anything wrong (and yes, I found there are some of those types around as well, unfortuantely).
And Saul, judging from your PMs about the shoes, I guess you're gonna settle on casein paint in the end ;-) )
interesting discussion, thanks for all your contributions. For me questions like this are a personal decision, depending on how close to original ways I can get and whether I can finance it. I do try to use materials as close to the original materials as possible, but I try to reproduce the end-product, not to reproduce ancient production itself and that is where I (roughly) draw the line. Thus I drill holes with a power drill or use saw and file to make a single, say, medical instrument from brass rather than casting it, etc. etc.
What actually is more important to me personally when talking about these things in detail with interested visitors/fellow reenactors is to openly admit to the compromises made and explain the reasoning behind instead of stubbornly maintaining to be a know-it-all who never does anything wrong (and yes, I found there are some of those types around as well, unfortuantely).
And Saul, judging from your PMs about the shoes, I guess you're gonna settle on casein paint in the end ;-) )
Cheers,
Martin
---------------
Martin Moser
http://www.legio8augusta.de
Leatherwork Through the Ages Homepage
Leatherwork Through the Ages Facebook Page
Martin
---------------
Martin Moser
http://www.legio8augusta.de
Leatherwork Through the Ages Homepage
Leatherwork Through the Ages Facebook Page