+- RomanArmyTalk (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat)
+-- Forum: Reenactment (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Roman Re-Enactment & Reconstruction (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Thread: Manica handguard (/showthread.php?tid=23574)
Manica handguard - Marcus Mummius - 02-19-2014
Hello all,
I have a quick question.
I know several manicae were found with plates to protect the hand of the wearer. But did all manicae that were found have such a handguard?
Best regards,
Manica handguard - Flavivs Aetivs - 02-19-2014
The Bowe Manica, dating to approximately 400AD in England, indeed had a plate to protect the hand and the thumb of the handle. The Carlisle Manica had a plate to protect the back of the hand.
However, I do not know if all did, I can think of a few examples that didn't (of course they could always be missing plates) but I cannot recall the names.
Manica handguard - Gaius Colletti - 02-20-2014
Several manica have been found with hand/finger coverage? I didn't even know we had recovered more than a few specimens that were complete enough. Hand/finger coverage although existing, wasn't universal
Manica handguard - Flavivs Aetivs - 02-20-2014
I would agree that most did not - in the east (I believe there was a find at Dura Europos? correct me if I'm wrong of course) that did not. The Carlisle Manica had a plate that protected the back of the hand up to about the knuckles, while the Bowe manica protected both the thumb and back of the hand.
Manica handguard - Caballo - 02-20-2014
This may be a helpful article with some pictures of the hand protection. http://www.comitatus.net/Documents/The_Manica_3.pdf
Personally, why wouldn't you have the back of your hand protected- it just requires a few small lames and your sword hand will be the most extended and exposed part.
Manica handguard - M. Val. Naso - 02-20-2014
Manicae did not protect your "hand" per se. They protected your index finger and a SMALL part of the back of your hand. So if you hold your sword pointing up and forward, it would defend against slashes coming downward on your hand.
Do any of you have info on this "Bowe Manica"? Google provided nothing. Literally.
Manica handguard - Marcus Mummius - 02-20-2014
Thanks for the input all.
Quote:This may be a helpful article with some pictures of the hand protection. http://www.comitatus.net/Documents/The_Manica_3.pdf
Personally, why wouldn't you have the back of your hand protected- it just requires a few small lames and your sword hand will be the most extended and exposed part.
Caballo, I have read your usefull article several times in the past :wink:
My question is a purely practical one. The manica I have (a very good reconstruction of the Carisle one) fits quite well. I have put a lining into it and use a strap and buckle system to secure it to my arm at several points. I'm still pondering on how to attach it to my shoulder/armour, using the upper cupric alloy rings.
The handguard fonctions very well when holding a gladius. I do experience some problems however when manupilating/throwing a pilum. Also the handguard sometimes bothers me when I am using the hastile as an optio during drill exercises.
So you see, purely a practical issue. If they existed without the handguard I am tempted to remove the few small lames from mine to have full mobility of my hand. But if they always seem to have had these lames protecting the back of the hand they have to stay of course and I will have to find another solution...
Valete,
Manica handguard - Flavivs Aetivs - 02-20-2014
Quote:Manicae did not protect your "hand" per se. They protected your index finger and a SMALL part of the back of your hand. So if you hold your sword pointing up and forward, it would defend against slashes coming downward on your hand.
Do any of you have info on this "Bowe Manica"? Google provided nothing. Literally.
Comitatus has a reconstruction here:
http://comitatus.net/galleryarmour.html
Not much different from any other manica.
Manica handguard - mcbishop - 02-20-2014
Quote:Manicae did not protect your "hand" per se. They protected your index finger and a SMALL part of the back of your hand. So if you hold your sword pointing up and forward, it would defend against slashes coming downward on your hand.It protected the exposed part of the hand which, since it is rotated to hold the sword and protected by the handguard, is just the root of the thumb (the index finger is well out of the way behind the handguard, unless you have an unusual way of holding it ;-) )
These small terminal trapezoidal plates are also found on the Eining manica, as well as the one from León.
Quote:Do any of you have info on this "Bowe Manica"? Google provided nothing. Literally.Helps if you have the right name. It was found in Bowes Moor signal tower and I wrote the report on it many years ago. I'll see if I can dig out a copy.
Mike Bishop
Manica handguard - M. Val. Naso - 02-20-2014
Mike, are you even capable of providing NOT useful information? I seriously doubt it. Cheers!
Manica handguard - mcbishop - 02-21-2014
Quote:Mike, are you even capable of providing NOT useful information?On the contrary, I am brimful of useless information (ask anyone who knows me), but just occasionally some more-or-less useful stuff creeps out ;-)
Mike Bishop
Manica handguard - Flavivs Aetivs - 02-21-2014
Quote:Mark George Little post=351321 Wrote:Mike, are you even capable of providing NOT useful information?On the contrary, I am brimful of useless information (ask anyone who knows me), but just occasionally some more-or-less useful stuff creeps out ;-)
Mike Bishop
Ha, I'm the exact same way.