+- RomanArmyTalk (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat)
+-- Forum: Reenactment (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Roman Re-Enactment & Reconstruction (https://www.romanarmytalk.com/rat/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Thread: Goat Skin Segmentata (/showthread.php?tid=10853)
Pages:
1
2
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - Dan Howard - 11-03-2007
Quote:I understand the same thing as Martin- that goatskin is the most puncture and abrasion-resistant type of leather, but what you'd have to find out is what it's stretchability is like. Given that it's used a lot for gloves because of its durability, data might be out there for its other characteristics...I think kangaroo leather has higher puncture resistance and sharkskin has better abrasion resistance. Goatskin is easier to acquire though and would be better than cattle or pigskin. The way it is tanned makes a big difference too.
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - M. Demetrius - 11-03-2007
Here in the US, deerskin is more commonly accessible than goat, seems like. And all ungulates' hides are pretty similar. Want a leather string that will flex, but rarely break? Pick deer, sheep, elk (red deer) or goat.
Want a leather strap that won't stretch and wears well? Pick bovine: cow water buffalo or bison.
Don't think I've tried sharkskin boot laces, but --
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - FAVENTIANVS - 11-04-2007
Quote:I see that I must be extremely specific with you gents. No I was not thinking about armor panels made of goat skin in some twisted twist on the Italian style. I was wondering if people thought they might be strong enough for the internal leathers. And just maybe whether any DNA testing had been done on the decomposed scraps of leather on the archaeological finds.[size=200:21uxl4q5]OK.[/size] :oops:
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - FAVENTIANVS - 11-04-2007
Quote:It's okay, Ivan, I think he's just yanking his Beloved Commander's chain. Though he does stay home all day with 3 hyper kids, so maybe he's finally gone around the old bend, eh?
Matthew
![[Image: cholorcoqp4.jpg]](http://img241.imageshack.us/img241/4707/cholorcoqp4.jpg)
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - Matt Lukes - 11-07-2007
Quote:Matt Lukes:3shlt48c Wrote:I understand the same thing as Martin- that goatskin is the most puncture and abrasion-resistant type of leather, but what you'd have to find out is what it's stretchability is like. Given that it's used a lot for gloves because of its durability, data might be out there for its other characteristics...I think kangaroo leather has higher puncture resistance and sharkskin has better abrasion resistance. Goatskin is easier to acquire though and would be better than cattle or pigskin. The way it is tanned makes a big difference too.
hock: I would've thought it obvious that exotic types weren't included, but guess I should have qualified that statement- okay, "among the commonly-available types of leather, for samples tanned the same way and of the same thickness, it's my understanding goatskin is the most puncture and abrasion-resistant."
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - Dan Howard - 11-07-2007
Kangaroo hide isn't that hard to acquire where I live. Best leather I ever saw. Nike purchased a specific permit to cull a pile of kangaroos for one of their top range football boots.
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - Primvs Pavlvs - 11-07-2007
I wonder if the Romans ever used two layers of thin goat leather. I know this would produce a stronger strap than one thick piece of leather.
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - M. Demetrius - 11-07-2007
Plaiting and braiding make even fairly stiff leather strings more resilient and flexible, and each strand adds at least as much strength as it possesses individually. A cord of three strands is not quickly torn apart.
Re: Goat Skin Segmentata - Robert Vermaat - 11-14-2007
Btw, I split off the silly stuff about Romans seeing kangaroos...